Missing the Mark: A 'School Report' on rich countries' contribution
to Universal Primary Education by 2015
A new "school report card" reveals that 100 million children
are still out of school because G7 and other rich countries are simply
failing to provide the funding needed for a quality education.
Click below to download report
| Country Marks
and Grades |
| Class position |
Country |
Marks
out of
100 |
Final
grade
(A-F) |
| 1st |
Norway |
100 |
A |
| 2nd |
Netherlands |
95 |
A |
| 3rd |
Denmark |
86 |
B |
| 4th |
Sweden |
84 |
B |
| 5th |
United Kingdom |
76 |
B |
| 6th |
Ireland |
74 |
B |
| 7th |
Canada |
65 |
C |
| 8th |
Switzerland |
59 |
C |
| 9th |
Belgium |
55 |
C |
| 10th |
Finland |
48 |
D |
| 11th |
France |
46 |
D |
| 12th |
Luxembourg |
41 |
D |
| 13th |
Portugal |
38 |
D |
| 14th |
Greece |
37 |
D |
| 15th |
Japan |
35 |
D |
| 16th |
Germany |
34 |
D |
| 17th |
Australia |
31 |
D |
| 18th |
Italy |
23 |
E |
| 18th |
Spain |
23 |
E |
| 19th |
New Zealand |
22 |
E |
| 20th |
USA |
18 |
F |
| 21st |
Austria |
11 |
F |
Missing the Mark: Report Summary
On a balmy September day in New York five years ago, heads of state
set themselves eight tough goals for ending global poverty: the Millennium
Development Goals. Among the most important of these was universal
completion of primary education.
Education, especially for girls, empowers families to break the cycle
of poverty for good. Young women with a primary education are twice
as likely to stay safe from AIDS, and their earnings will be 10-20
per cent higher for every year of schooling completed. Evidence gathered
over 30 years shows that educating women is the single most powerful
weapon against malnutrition - even more effective than improving food
supply. Without universal primary education, the other Millennium
Development Goals - stopping AIDS, halving the number of people living
in poverty, ending unnecessary hunger and child death, amongst others
- are not going to be achieved.
Rich countries' aid to education is producing results. Over the past
five years, primary school fees have been abolished in many African
countries, and as children flood into schools, aid has helped to provide
tens of thousands more teachers and classrooms. Africa's gross enrolments
have risen to over 90 per cent and, as a result, an estimated 17 million
more children, especially girls, are getting an education.
However, despite recent gains, over 60 million girls and 40 million
boys are still out of school. The first Millennium Development Goal
- equal numbers of girls as boys attending school by 2005 - has already
been missed, and according to UNICEF, 9 million more girls than boys
are left out of school every year. To give every girl and boy a decent
primary education by 2015, recent rates of progress need to double
in South Asia and quadruple in Africa.
It is therefore deeply worrying that bilateral and multilateral aid
to basic education in low income countries, although it increased
to $1.7bn in 2003, is still only about one-fifth of what is needed.
For only $5.4bn more per year, we could provide a quality, free education
to every child, and unlock the full power of education to beat poverty.
This amounts to less than two and a half days' global military spending.
For the price of just one of the Cruise missiles dropped on Baghdad,
100 schools could be built in Africa.
However, our research shows that rich countries are still falling
well short of the financing targets they set themselves, although
some countries, such as Norway, the Netherlands, Sweden, and Denmark,
are performing well. The chief laggards are Austria, the USA, New
Zealand, Spain, and Italy. Five of the G7 countries are in the bottom
half of the class, with a combined grade of 'D'. The two richest countries
in the world, the USA and Japan, languish at the bottom of the class,
providing less than 10 per cent of their fair share of support to
education for all.
Donor nations have launched an 'Education for All Fast Track Initiative'
(FTI) to ensure that developing countries that come forward with good
policies and clear plans for achieving education for all are rewarded
by increased aid. The Fast Track Initiative has the potential to become
an effective global partnership to achieve quality, free education
for all, inspiring and enabling dramatically-increased efforts by
both rich and poor countries. It is not such a partnership yet: it
includes too few developing countries, mobilises too little in additional
funding, and lacks clear and certain guarantees from the rich world.
Some 40 per cent of the additional aid promised to the first 12 Fast
Track Initiative countries has yet to arrive.
Without an ambitious expansion of the Fast Track Initiative, progress
in developing countries is likely to remain insufficient to achieve
the education Millennium Development Goals in the short ten years
remaining. To reach the goals, both developing and developed countries
will have to work together to do more, do it faster, and do it better.
That is why we need rich countries to back the Education for All Fast
Track Initiative, and pledge enough resources to expand the FTI to
all poor countries that come forward with credible and transparent
plans for achieving the education goals.
1 Abu-Ghaida, D. and S. Klasen (2004) 'The
Economic and Human Development Costs of Missing the Millennium Development
Goal on Gender Equity', World Bank Discussion Paper 29710 (Washington:
World Bank). Smith, L. and L. Haddad (2001) 'Explaining Child Malnutrition
in Developing Countries,' International Food Policy Research Institute
Research Report No. 111 (Washington DC: International Food Policy
Research Institute). Global Campaign for Education (2004) Learning
to Survive: How Education for All Would Save Millions of Young People
from HIV/AIDS (London: GCE). Psacharapoulos, G. and H. Patrinos (2002)
'Returns to Investment in Education: A Further Update', World Bank
Policy Research Working Paper 2881 (Washington: World Bank)
11 Based on trends in
primary completion 1990-2001, as reported in the FTI Status Report,
December 2004.
111
Global Movement for Children (2005) 'But the Children Cannot Wait:
What Governments Must Do This Year to Fulfill the Promises Made to
Children in the Millennium Declaration and Goals', March 2005 (processed).
According to the three-year targets and budgets approved by donors,
the first 12 FTI partner countries needed a total of $1.7bn in aid
to finance the first three years of their UPE strategies (2003-2005),
on top of $5bn of their own money. As of the end of 2004, only 1.05bn
had been committed. These figures exclude Ethiopia, the most recently
endorsed country, which faces a financing gap of some $200m per year.
FTI Secretariat (2004), 'EFA-FTI Status Report', prepared for the
EFA-FTI Annual Meeting, Nov 10-12, 2004 (revised December 2004). As
noted above, more recent donor pledges may improve the situation slightly
for some countries, but unfortunately no comprehensive information
was available on 2005 pledges. See Box 2 for more information on the
most recent pledges.
|
 |
|